Published: October 13, 2026 / Last updated: October 15, 2026
There are many ways to decide shifts besides Shiftto. Which is best depends on the size and length of the event and how fine-grained the information you need is. Here I sort out what each kind of method does well and badly. I don't name specific products or prices; I describe tendencies by type. I also write about when Shiftto doesn't fit.
For a short one-off event, the heavy parts are usually the second to the fourth. Asking by the hour and assigning people to meet the headcount per role is what gets hardest by hand.
| Method | Does well | Does badly |
|---|---|---|
| Asking in a LINE group | Everyone already uses it, and it is quick to start | Replies scroll away and tallying stays manual. With many slots people stop following the format |
| Forms and a spreadsheet | Free-form fields; free, and enough for a small group | Copying answers into the table and trial-and-error assignment stay manual |
| Scheduling services | Picking one date that suits everyone from candidates | Many are built around which days are free, and don't handle headcount per role or assignment |
| Monthly or weekly shift apps | Long-term operation with fixed members; some handle attendance and payroll | They assume registered members, so the effort is large for an event over in a few days. Many are paid |
| Shiftto | Starts with just a URL. Set slots and headcount per role and it assigns automatically | No attendance or payroll management. Not for fixed-member weekly shifts |
The table shows general tendencies by type. Features differ between services within the same type, so check each service's current description before you use it.
Shiftto is built only for one-off and short-term events. For that reason it deliberately leaves out some of what other methods cover.
How it came about, and what real use taught me, are written up in the operator's story article.
In the following cases another method fits better.
Also, Shiftto currently has no feature for setting a response deadline automatically and no way to reissue an admin PIN yourself (if you forget it, you contact us through the Contact page). If you need those, cover them in how you run things, or consider another method.
You don't have to switch to just one. For example, you can keep talking on LINE as before and leave only collecting availability and assigning to Shiftto. Results export to CSV, so you can load them into a spreadsheet and shape them into your usual table.
You can see what the resulting table looks like on the demo page, which shows the output of running the real assignment algorithm on sample answers.
Collect availability and build the shifts automatically
No sign-up or login. Free, and ready in 5 minutes.
Create a shift